Uber loses VAT margin scheme appeal
The Court of Appeal has ruled that Uber cannot use the Tour Operators Margin Scheme (TOMS) when accounting for VAT on its ride-hailing services. The decision could have significant implications for businesses that act as intermediaries when supplying services to consumers. What was the dispute about?
The case concerned whether Uber could account for VAT under the TOMS, which allows businesses to pay VAT on their profit margin rather than the full value of a supply. The scheme is most commonly associated with the travel industry, but Uber argued that it should also apply to journeys arranged through its platform. HMRC disagreed, arguing that the services supplied by Uber did not fall within the scope of the TOMS. The Court of Appeal has now sided with HMRC, concluding that the scheme was not available in the circumstances. As a result, VAT must be accounted for under the normal rules rather than on the margin alone.
The financial implications are potentially significant. Applying VAT to the full value of journeys rather than the margin increases the amount of VAT due and may affect the commercial viability of certain business models that rely on acting as an intermediary between customers and service providers. Although the case focused on ride-hailing services, the decision may have wider relevance for businesses operating digital platforms and marketplace models. Companies that have considered using the TOMS outside traditional travel arrangements may need to review their VAT treatment in light of the judgment.
The ruling is another reminder that VAT schemes designed for specific sectors cannot automatically be extended to new business models, even where there are similarities in how services are supplied.
Related Topics
-
CT61
-
Could refinancing your property put mortgage interest relief at risk?
HMRC has changed its guidance on claiming tax relief for interest on loans used to replace capital withdrawn from a business. The Chartered Institute of Taxation (CIOT) has now challenged the revised guidance, warning that it creates uncertainty for landlords, sole traders and partnerships. Could your borrowing arrangements be affected?
-
HMRC text or scam? Check before you act
HMRC is contacting some taxpayers by text this week about overdue Self Assessment liabilities and is also sending updates about VAT registration applications. At the same time, it has expanded its guidance on spotting fake HMRC messages on social media. How can you tell whether a message is genuine?
This website uses both its own and third-party cookies to analyze our services and navigation on our website in order to improve its contents (analytical purposes: measure visits and sources of web traffic). The legal basis is the consent of the user, except in the case of basic cookies, which are essential to navigate this website.